How To Be Yourself In Your Content: The Gentle Guide For Leaders Struggling With Authenticity

If you have ever sat staring at a blank screen thinking, "I want to be myself in my content, but I have no idea what that even looks like," this is for you.

I hear versions of this all the time from founders and leaders:
"I do not want to sound fake."
"I am scared people will think I am trying too hard."
"I want to be real, but I also want to look competent."

Those are not small worries. They are tied to very real fears of embarrassment, being judged, or coming across as a fraud.

So let us slow this right down and talk about what it actually means to be genuine in your content, and how to do it in a way that feels honest, confident and sustainable.

What authenticity in content really means

There is a stat that gets quoted a lot, around sixty per cent of people say they would rather buy from a brand they see as genuine.

That matters, but here is the part most people miss, being genuine is not a marketing trick. It is not a style choice. It is you letting how you actually think, speak and make decisions show up in public.

In practice, that means:

• You sound like yourself on a good day, not like a press release.
• Your stories line up with how you act with your team and clients.
• You are willing to show some of the messy middle, not only the polished outcome.

When you do that, people feel like they know you a little, even before they meet you. That is where trust starts.

Projecting an image versus living your values

A lot of leaders tell me they feel stuck between two versions of themselves.

On one side, there is the "public" version, carefully worded posts, corporate tone, phrases you would never say out loud to a friend. That is you projecting an image you think the world expects.

On the other side, there is the "real" version, how you talk in the office, what you actually believe about your industry, the stories you tell over coffee. That is closer to who you are.

Projecting is when you push out a character you think will be accepted.
Personifying, to use the original term, is when you let your actual values and quirks show through what you say and how you show up.

You know you are stuck in projection mode when:

• You re read every sentence five times to make it sound more official.
• You hit publish and immediately feel flat, because it does not feel like you.
• You get engagement, but not from the people you really want to reach.

Living your values looks quieter from the outside, but it feels better inside. You recognise yourself in your own content. You do not have to remember which version of you said what.

That is where confidence begins. Not louder, just truer.

A simple mental reset when you feel fake

Even when you care about being genuine, you will have days where you slip into a mask.

Maybe you catch yourself performing on camera.
Maybe you write a post and think, "That sounds like a corporate brochure, not me."

When that happens, you do not need a grand reset. You just need a short one.

Here is a three step reset you can use in five minutes.

Pause and breathe
Step away from the screen or camera. Take three slow breaths. This is not a wellness trick. It just gives your nervous system a moment to calm down so your brain can do more than defend and perform.

Ask one honest question
"What did I actually want to say here, before I started worrying how it would look?"
Let yourself answer in rough language. If it helps, say it out loud the way you would to a trusted colleague.

Rewrite one level closer to how you speak
Do not throw the whole thing away. Take one paragraph or one line and rewrite it in your own words. Shorter, plainer, more direct. That tiny shift starts to pull the rest of the piece back toward you.

You will not move from performance to full honesty in a single step. But each small reset pulls you closer to the version of you that feels real.

How being genuine supports your confidence

There is a quiet relief that comes when you stop pretending.

When your content matches who you are, a few things tend to happen:

You worry less about being "found out"
You are not holding up a persona, so there is nothing to maintain. What people see in your content is very close to what they will get in a call or a room.

You stop chasing approval from everyone
You know what you stand for and who you are speaking to. Some people will move closer. Others will move on. That is healthy. Your self worth is less tied to likes or views.

You handle silence better
A post that gets modest numbers, but feels like you, hurts much less than a post that performs but feels false. Over time, that steadiness builds real confidence.

Being genuine will not remove every wobble in your self esteem. But it gives you firmer ground to stand on. You are no longer trying to hold up a mask while you talk.

Why self compassion matters for honest content

One of the fastest ways to kill your own voice is constant self attack.

If every time you speak up you judge yourself harder than anyone else would, you will shrink. You will edit out anything human. You will default to safe, flat content, because it does not expose you.

Self compassion is not about letting yourself off the hook. It is about speaking to yourself the way you would to a friend who is trying something brave.

In practice, that might look like:

• Allowing mistakes on camera, and not re recording fifteen times.
• Posting a piece that is clear and helpful, even if it is not flawless.
• Noticing when you are spiralling in criticism, and choosing to pause rather than pile on.

Over time, this kinder internal voice gives you enough stability to be more open. You can share a hard lesson or a vulnerable story without shredding yourself afterwards.

That steadiness is what lets you be consistently genuine, not just on your good days.

How negative thoughts block your real voice

Most leaders I work with have a very sharp inner critic. It sounds like:

"They will think this is obvious."
"I am not qualified enough to say this."
"Everyone already covered this topic."

Left alone, that voice does three things.

It makes you doubt your experience
You start discounting the years you have put into your craft, simply because you are aware of what you do not know.

It turns normal risk into catastrophe in your mind
Posting a simple story can feel as risky as stepping on stage in front of thousands, even if it is just your LinkedIn feed.

It silences your best ideas
The more human, honest thoughts never see the light of day. You keep them for private conversations and give the internet only safe, generic updates.

You do not have to fight those thoughts directly. Instead, you can start to question them.

• Is this thought a fact, or just a fear?
• Compared to what my actual clients ask me, is this really too basic?
• If a colleague said this to me, what would I say back to them?

You will not delete the critic altogether. But you can turn down its volume enough to let your real voice through.

Showing up as yourself with your network

Being genuine with your network is not about oversharing or turning every post into a diary.

It is much simpler.

It is about:

• Saying what you actually think about topics in your field, not what you think will sound clever.
• Sharing stories from real projects or real days, not only polished case studies.
• Letting your natural tone and rhythm show, rather than copying the style of whoever is popular this month.

Practical ways to do this:

• When you comment on someone else's post, add one honest thought from your own experience instead of a generic line.
• When you share a win, add one line of what was hard about getting there.
• When you share a lesson, mention where you first learned it, even if it came from a mistake.

People notice when there is an actual person behind the words. They lean in.

Building real business relationships through honest communication

Strong business relationships start in very ordinary ways: a message that feels human, a call where you listen properly, an email that sounds like it was written by one person to another.

To build that kind of connection:

Listen for the feeling under the problem
When someone says, "We are struggling with content," they might really mean, "We are scared of looking foolish in public." If you can respond to that deeper feeling, they will feel seen.

Speak plainly
Avoid the urge to hide behind buzzwords. If what you mean is "We will help you show up more often with less stress," say that. Clear beats clever every time.

Respect each person's story
Every client, colleague and partner has their own background, pressures and wins. When you show curiosity about that, it changes the tone of the relationship.

Over time, this approach shifts you from "vendor" to trusted human partner. People come back not only because of what you do, but because of how it feels to work with you.

Simple ways to feel more confident in your content

Confidence is not a personality trait that some people have and others do not. It is mostly the byproduct of three simple habits.

Know who you are talking to
Picture one real person from your audience when you write or record. What are they worried about this week? What language do they use? How can you make their day a little easier?
When you write for one person, your message sharpens and your nerves calm.

Prioritise quality over volume
You do not need to post every day. You do need to post things you stand behind. A steady rhythm of clear, helpful pieces will grow your confidence faster than a flood of rushed posts that do not feel like you.

Keep learning, quietly
Read, listen, test things in your own work. You do not need to announce every learning step. Just let your content reflect the fact that you are paying attention and staying curious. That quiet depth is where your authority grows.

The more you see your content genuinely help real people, the easier it is to keep showing up.

Attracting the right people by being sincere

One of the surprising gifts of being genuine is that it acts like a filter.

When you share what you actually think, and how you actually work, a few things happen:

The wrong people quietly move on
If someone wants fluff, or wants you to pretend to be someone you are not, they will often disqualify themselves. That is a blessing.

The right people feel an immediate click
They hear their own worries and hopes in your words. They feel less alone. They think, "This person gets it."

The working relationship starts on honest ground
You do not have to spend the first three months of a project trying to correct a false impression. They already know your tone, your pace, what you care about.

This is especially true in video and on platforms like LinkedIn. When people see your face, hear your voice and feel your real pace and manner, they make a call very quickly: "Is this someone I could trust?"

You cannot fake that for long. And you do not need to.

A gentle closing thought

If you take nothing else from this, take this: you are allowed to sound like yourself in your content.

You do not need a different voice for the internet. You need a clearer version of the one you already use when you are helping someone one to one.

Start small. One more honest line in your next post. One less take on your next video. One kinder thought directed at yourself after you share something.

Those little choices add up. Bit by bit, you become the same person on the page, on camera and in the room.

And that is where people start to trust you, not just for what you know, but for who you are.

‍